Can you substitute tonic water for soda water?
You can, but it will completely change the drink. Replacing tonic with soda removes the bitterness, resulting in a lighter, less complex flavour. On the other hand, swapping soda for tonic makes a cocktail more aromatic. If you want a closer match, opt for sparkling water or seltzer instead of soda.
For more ways to experiment with G&T flavours, check out our favourite variations of a gin and tonic.
Tonic vs soda water: which is better?
There’s no right answer—it all depends on your taste. If you love a bold, slightly bitter edge, tonic water is your go-to. If you prefer a lighter, more refreshing serve that lets the gin shine, soda water is the way forward. Either way, Beefeater Gin’s carefully picked botanicals makes it the perfect base for both.
Discover more gin mixers to try with Beefeater as well as our guide on how to order a G&T to guarantee a great drink.